Flipkart challenges Gujarat entry tax on online sale in HC

April 30, 2016
1 min read

[Source: timesofindia.indiatimes.com]

The Gujarat high court on Thursday issued notice to the advocate general and state authorities concerned over a petition filed by India’s largest online marketplace Flipkart Internet Pvt Ltd objecting to state government’s law levying entry tax on goods sold in Gujarat through online shopping.

This happened after the state government made amendments in its Gujarat Tax on Entry of Specified Goods into Local Areas Act, 2001, on March 31 and came up with a notification the next day.

The state government introduced the entry tax in the state budget 2016-17 on e-tailers to provide a level playing field to local dealers, who claim to be at the receiving end of the competition. The government directed the e-tailers to charge the difference in value added tax (VAT) rates between Gujarat and the state from where a product is supplied as entry tax. Similar mechanism would apply to locally made goods, which are sold in other states.

Flipkart’s main objection to this is that it is not engaged in any sale of goods to customers, but merely a service provider — an online platform for sellers and buyers where sellers can list their products and buyers can place orders. Here the buyers purchase goods directly from the sellers and its website makes it amply clear that the goods are for end users and not for resale.

While seeking quashing of the provisions recently introduced in the law, the petitioner submitted that the sellers are registered under respective states under VATCentral Sales Tax laws (CST) and it is displayed on the website. In case where goods are situated outside Gujarat, the seller pay appropriate CST on such goods. Flipkart further argued that a package along with invoice is handed over to the logistics agents by the sellers for the delivery directly to the customers. Thus the service provider’s role is nothing more than providing an online platform and managing the logistics.

With this argument, the petitioner has urged the court to junk the entry tax provision on goods on which CST has been already paid.

After hearing the case, a bench of Chief Justice R S Reddy and Justice V M Pancholi has sought the state government and sales tax commissioner’s reply by June 3, said Flipkart’s advocate Dhaval K Shah.

Previous Story

Is higher service tax fuelling black money in the system?

Next Story

Budget 2016 enacted on 14-May – Service Tax Amendments effective from various dates

Latest from Blog

Income Tax deduction for procurements from MSMEs only upon actual payment

By Shaleen Shah | LinkedIn, assisted by Divyansh Jain Introduction This Note is relevant to computation of income under the head ‘Income from business and profession’. Section 43B of the Income Tax Act provides a list of expenses allowed as deduction, on cash basis irrespective of the year of accounting.

Foreign companies may be required to file Tax Returns in India

by Nexdigm Private Limited as published on mondaq.com Impact of increase in withholding tax on rates for Fees for Technical Services and Royalty As per Indian Tax laws1, payments made to Non-Residents/Foreign Companies for Fees for Technical Services (FTS) and Royalties were liable to tax at the effective tax rate of

How Cryptocurrencies Are Taxed In India

[Source: forbes.com; Authors: Justin M Bharucha, Aashika Jain] Cryptocurrencies and non-fungible tokens (NFTs) are presently unregulated in India. While the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) had sought to ban cryptocurrencies in 2018, the Supreme Court quashed the attempted ban leaving cryptocurrencies in regulatory limbo – neither illegal nor, strictly speaking,

Higher rate of TDS in certain situations from 1st July 2021

[By Shaleen Shah (Partner), VNCA] Finance Act 2021, has introduced a new section 206AB effective from 1-Jul-2021 wherein a payer/buyer is responsible to deduct TDS at higher rate (i.e. twice the rate as specified under the relevant provision of the Income Tax Act or twice the rate/ rates in force;

Don't Miss

How Cryptocurrencies Are Taxed In India

[Source: forbes.com; Authors: Justin M Bharucha, Aashika Jain] Cryptocurrencies and

Only 329 startups can claim tax holiday under Startup India

[Source: cnbctv18.com] Exactly five years since the launch of the